I should preface this review by saying I enjoy surprises to an extent. I like having control, and yes, I realize that directly contradicts liking surprises. You’re probably already thinking it… at times, I’m a walking enigma.
Over the summer, my husband and I celebrated my birthday. He planned a surprise date night — the surprise was the dinner location not the outing itself. After being given clues earlier that day (he told me the restaurant only seated around 18 guests at a time, probably too specific of a clue), I was able to guess that we were going to dinner at Omakase. This gave me the entire drive up to the city to think about the likelihood that the menu would be composed solely of raw fish. I enjoy sushi and sashimi so this wouldn’t usually be an issue, but I’ve never sat through an entire meal of raw fare so I was concerned about the potential pyrotechnics that might occur in my stomach after eating.
The literal translation of omakase is respectfully leaving another to decide what is best. In the context of a meal at a Japanese restaurant, it simply means the dishes that make up the meal are chef’s choice. I wasn’t really sure what to expect except fish.
The meal started with a complimentary Ryu sake. Sake is a Japanese rice wine produced through a brewing process similar to that of beer. I am not a big sake drinker, for no reason except that I just haven’t had much experience with it, so my only comment here is that it was chilled, mild, and easy to guzzle down. Mirugai (giant clam) and mountain yam were served as the amuse bouche. It wasn’t a combination I would have thought to expect. Nevertheless, it was tasty and a great start to what turned out to be a phenomenal meal. I’ll include a full list of the dishes below.
My favorite dishes were the mirugai and Maine lobster tail, lobster tsunomono (in this case vinegar-soaked cucumber), aji (Japanese horse mackerel), and the Wagyu beef with wasabi, sea salt, and truffle soy. Everything was extremely fresh. At another restaurant the items might have been rubbery and smelled strongly of fish, but not here. I’ve never been fond of mackerel, but I was blown away by how fresh and mild it tasted. There were so many mackerel dishes; you can bet they had to be fresh for me to get through all of them.
My least favorite was the custard with Hokkaido uni (sea urchin). The flavor was savory and not bad at all. I think I was perplexed by the semi-solid texture and lukewarm temperature. My husband thoroughly enjoyed it; it was just my own personal taste that prevented me from doing so.
Summary: I told my husband that this dinner absolutely ruined sashimi for me. When am I going to get the same quality, freshness, and creativity again? The flavors were fantastic — fresh, tart, and savory in all the right combinations. The fish was exquisite, flown in three times a week from the famed Tsukiji Fish Market in Tokyo. It’s hard to judge portion size because the majority of the dishes were sashimi, but we must have had over 20 dishes all in all including the amuse bouche and the dessert so I would say portion size was good. I believe we purchased the Yamato Omakase, a whopping $200 per person. This was out of the ordinary for us. While the food was excellent, I think I would go for a more affordable offering next time. The atmosphere was intimate… dim lighting, quiet conversation, and as I mentioned earlier, limited seating. I think the restaurant only offers two services a day. And the service! The servers were attentive, and the chefs were highly-skilled in Edomae (traditional style sushi). They took us on a journey as they explained the food. I learned so much while I was there (FYI apparently all good shellfish is from Hokkaido). They were also kind enough to fire some of the fish directly in front of us so we could take photos, take a picture with me behind the counter after our service, and sign a birthday card for me.
I highly recommend saving up to celebrate a special occasion at Omakase. Things you should know: due to limited seating reservations are required, you’ll need to provide your credit card information to hold your reservation, and you’ll need to be prepared for parking in SF which may mean paying the meter.
For more information, check out their website: http://omakasesf.com
Full meal:
- Ryu sake
- mirugai and mountain yam
- tartare, cherry tomato, tofu mousse – surprisingly tasty and I don’t even love tomatoes
- bluefin tuna of varying levels of fat
- custard with uni
- mirugai and Maine lobster tail
- lobster tsunomono
- soy-marinated toro (medium fatty tuna)
- kasugo dai (baby sebring)
- shimahaji (belly side of striped jackfish)
- samara (king mackerel) with grated daikon radish
- aji (horse mackerel)
- kinmedai (golden big-eyed snapper)
- hotate gai (Hokkaido sea scallop) with yuzu pepper sauce and lemon zest
- otoro (fatty tuna from Nagasaki)
- masaba (mackerel) with marinated white kelp
- kamasu (barracuda) with spicy daikon and green onion
- uni with house-marinated ikura (salmon roe)
- anago (sea eel)
- tamago yaki (egg cake) with lobster
- Wagyu beef with wasabi, sea salt, and truffle soy
- lobster agedashi (dusted with starch and deep fried)
- sorbet with fresh flowers and kome kome (I think this is something to do with uncooked rice)
Until next time…

